Why Do Physical Therapists Hate CrossFit?

BY LYNDSAY DEFILIPPO, DPT, RAUSCH PHYSICAL THERAPY

Okay, let me begin by stating that all PTs do NOT hate CrossFit! In fact, there are many physical therapists who participate in and praise the workout. While CrossFit has been around for awhile, founded in 2000, it’s become increasingly popular in the last few years; there are televised CrossFit Games, uber-popular social media accounts for CrossFit Athletes/overnight celebrities, and—at the heart of it all—the local boxes popping up on every corner, delivering daily workouts that tend to be as addictive as they are intense.

My first experience with CrossFit was as an observer while I was still living back on the East Coast. I was invited by one of my patients, a CrossFit coach, whom I was also treating for a shoulder injury.  A coworker and I woke up way earlier than normal one morning to check out this phenomenon first hand. Walking into the box that morning, I was greeted with blaring music, a vast open space with very minimal equipment, and a bunch of pumped-up people who were clearly more awake at 6 a.m. than me.

Why CrossFit Athletes are Getting Injured

As a Doctor of Physical Therapy, I cringed every time I saw someone performing an improper squat, and grimaced as I quickly assessed the amount of weight being lifted with those poor mechanics. My immediate thought? “I’m going to see a lot of these folks in my practice sooner rather than later!” However, during the workout, I was also surprised to see components of stretching and cardio interspersed between the heavy lifting, and slowly I began to see how people could become so addicted to CrossFit.

Nevertheless, I was still concerned about the lack of form and focus on mechanics that I’d seen in some of the participants. So, in the following days I did more research; I quickly realized that CrossFit actually goes deeper than the stereotypical  “bros who lift” or “those who drink the CrossFit Kool-Aid.”

I learned that while each CrossFit box (what most of us refer to as gym) is a privately owned-and-operated entity, each being connected through a uniform Workout of the Day (WOD.) Coaches and trainers are there to direct, motivate and push members through each WOD, offering guidance to maintain form and offer ways to scale or modify certain lifts. I was also pleasantly surprised to discover that CrossFit offers a multitude of training and certification programs, which address movement patterns, lifting techniques, defense training, methodology, etc.

So with all of these proper form-and-function bases seemingly covered, and with so much emphasis on the overall health of the athletes themselves, why are we seeing increased injuries in CrossFit enthusiasts?

Quality Control

My theory? Since each CrossFit box is its own franchise, I think it’s safe to say that not all CrossFit boxes are created equal. Like any gym, the experience and safety within a session is only as good as the coaches or trainers who are leading the workouts. So while I think the CrossFit model itself is exceptional, I fear that not all leaders are following the guidelines, and this is why we are seeing a majority of CrossFitters making their way into PT offices.

The CrossFit Workout Itself

The nature of CrossFit—repeated lifting with increased weight, intensity-based within a short time frame—lends itself to a plethora of injuries.

When it comes to Olympic-style lifting, maintaining form through each movement is crucial, as is having proper mobility and movement patterns established prior to adding the speed factor. In CrossFit, people fatigue during timed workouts, which inevitably causes a break in form and puts them at risk for injury.

Overuse injuries are another concern with CrossFit. Overuse of the body in one plane can lead to an increase in soft-tissue injuries, such as tendonitis and muscle tears. To combat this issue, try adding other HIIT/circuit programs that have an emphasis on rotational planes, lateral planes, and muscle confusion to your weekly workout routine; they’re not only kick-ass workouts, but they’ll also help you avoid overstress in one muscle group. This is similar to the theory of why three-season athletes see fewer injuries than those who specialize in one sport year round.

Most Common CrossFit Injuries

As a physical therapist with quite a few CrossFit patients, I’d say that 25% of the injuries I see are knee, hip or back-related, while the rest are shoulder injuries (which makes total sense considering CrossFit requires a lot of upper-extremity movement.)  Most lower extremity injuries come from improper hip hinge, decreased ankle mobility, poor gluteal firing, and poor lower extremity mechanics. For my shoulder patients, I find a majority of them are hurt because they don’t have full range of motion in their shoulder or sufficient thoracic spine mobility, which can cause serious compensations and, inevitably, injuries.

A good friend of mine and fellow physical therapist C. Shante Cofield, PT, DPT, OCS, CSCS has broken into the CrossFit field, offering amazing tips on her Instagram page, breaking down the movement patterns most CrossFitters struggle with and teaching them how to correct to avoid injuries. Shante and I often chat to geek out about movement patterns, so I asked for her thoughts on the relationship between the shoulders and hips when performing Olympic-style lifts:

Shoulder injuries are often a result of doing too much too soon, as well as poor stabilization. CrossFit incorporates Olympic lifts and certain gymnastics movements, both of which utilize the hips for momentum and force production. Since the hips are much bigger than the shoulders, it’s imperative that you train your shoulder to be strong enough to accept that force. Additionally, traditional CrossFit-training tends to focus on strengthening the larger, prime movers of the shoulder, which ultimately overpower the (less-often trained*) stabilizing muscles. All of this leads to injury.]

* Your PT can help you to understand these “less-trained” muscle groups, and avoid future injuries.

 

Five Ways to Avoid CrossFit Injuries

 

  1. Have your form, mobility, and strength assessed by a professional before starting CrossFit. If there are deficits in any of those, fix them before starting.
  2. Don’t let adrenaline overpower your body’s pain-response. Our bodies feel pain as a result of injury—don’t brush it off.
  3. Use a PVC pipe to focus on form. Once you begin CrossFit, spend more time with a PVC pipe to really address form prior to adding weight, repetitions, speed or intensity.
  4. Don’t forget to work the understated muscles, like the rotator cuff, scapular stabilizers, transverse abdominus, etc. They may not be the “pretty muscles,” but they will ensure overall body stability.
  5. Learn and improve your body awareness. This is actually something people struggle with in almost every situation on a daily basis. Learn how to utilize dissociative movement patterns to your advantage.

 

Conclusion

Again, all physical therapists do NOT hate CrossFit; most of us just want to make sure that there’s a greater emphasis on form and movement, instead of reaching a PR or adding weight before you’re ready.

Seeing a physical therapist is not only a great way to assess form and function weaknesses once you’re injured, it’s also a good way to spot poor mechanics before starting a program with such high physical demands, such as CrossFit. So whether you’re a seasoned pro or you’re thinking about stepping into the box for the first time, do your research, take the time to learn the proper fundamentals, and go see a licensed physical therapist; I guarantee you’ll see better workouts, better results, and fewer injuries.

 


Lyndsay DeFilippo PT, DPT, CKTP received her Doctorate of Physical Therapy from New York University in 2010. She’s a Graston Practitioner and a Certified Kinesiotaping Practitioner. Lyndsay looks at each injury as a constantly changing puzzle, which is only solved when her patient returns to what s/he loves doing. She enjoys helping with the full recovery process, which includes providing the education, tools and fundamentals to prevent re-injury and the potential for new injuries.

Click to learn more about Lyndsay and our other physical therapists »

The Myth of the “Ergonomic Workplace”


BY KEVIN CAPATA, DPT, RAUSCH PHYSICAL THERAPY

Should I get a standing desk? Do I need a chair with a lumbar-support cushion? Is it okay to cross my legs? How can I keep correct posture for eight hours at work!?

As a physical therapist, my patients ask me these types of questions far too often. I can understand why; we’ve heard that sitting at a desk all day is (literally) killing us, we can feel the aches and pains of the 40-hour work week, and we want a quick fix. Enter: “The Ergonomic Workstation”—the latest “solution” to the daily grind.

We’ve all heard or read about the ideal “ergonomic” setup for your office, and people will spend hundreds of dollars on products to achieve it. Try a treadmill desk. Swap out your chair for a stability ball. Get an ergonomic keyboard. Sit up straight… no, lean back… NO, stand up! From desk accessories to office furniture, my patients are buying anything that promises to alleviate their poor posture and the pain that comes with it—but is this money well spent?

The Myth of the “Ergonomic Workplace”

Now, I believe that ergonomic products are great in theory, and yes an “ergonomic” set up at your office may help correct some “poor” posture during your workday. But as a physical therapist, I’m here to let you in on a secret: it doesn’t really matter what kind of chair you use or how you sit at your desk; what matters is YOU.

Yep, when it comes down to it, the ergonomic workstation is a myth. The truth is, being desk-bound and sedentary is what’s killing us.

When you’re at your desk for hours, it doesn’t matter how you’re sitting, or if you’re standing, or even if you’re walking on a treadmill—if you do the same movement or hold the same position for a prolonged period, it’s unhealthy. You can be sitting in the most ergonomic chair money can buy, but if you sit in it for hours at a time, your body will adapt and struggle to function when you’re no longer in that position, which is why you feel that soreness, stiffness and pain.

So yes, always sitting hunched forward at your computer is bad, BUT always sitting stick straight is not great either. Maintaining ANY position all day, every day is not good for you! As biomechanist Katy Bowman puts it in one of my favorite books, “It’s not the load that breaks you down, it’s the way you carry it.”

DID YOU KNOW? The Average American is Sedentary for 21 Hours Per Day

In fact, sitting has joined smoking and obesity as a top risk factor for chronic disease. Recent studies show that too much sitting contributes to a host of diseases—from obesity and diabetes to cancer and depression—and literally shortens your life.

Right down to the cellular level, our bodies crave frequent and varied movement. Yet I bet you can count the number of positions you are in throughout the day on one hand:

  1. Walk to your car
  2. Sit while you drive, at work, for meals, while watching TV…
  3. Lie down to sleep

In total, Americans are sitting an average of 13 hours a day and sleeping an average of eight hours, resulting in a sedentary lifestyle of around 21 hours per day. Sure, maybe you squeeze in a trip to the gym, but when you think about it, a sedentary lifestyle plus an hour of “exercise” is like eating candy and junk food all day, then deciding to have an apple for dinner!

The British Medical Journal claims that reducing the average time you spend sitting to less than three hours per day could increase your life expectancy by two years, but that’s definitely easier said than done considering that 13-hour average. So, what can we do to get—and stay—moving?

Stay Moving, Stay Healthy

It’s time to forget this notion that there’s one “best” work setup or posture; instead realize that the best position is your next position. Get up. MOVE. Change positions. Get into a new posture that you haven’t tried in a while. You don’t have to allow your environment to determine how you interact with it.
[framedbox]
[styled_title size=”2″]Kevin’s Three Rules for Avoiding Sitting[/styled_title]
Bound to your desk? Here are three rules to remember throughout your workday to help restore proper function to your tissues and muscles and combat sitting at work:

  1. For every 30 to 45 minutes of sitting, you should do five minutes of stretching or mobilization exercises
  2. Set an alarm for every 20 to 30 minutes to remind you to change positions. We all have smart phones, so no excuses!
  3. Find alternative positions to work in (e.g. kneel/stretch in front of your desk, use a headset and pace while on the phone, etc.)

EXAMPLES OF ALTERNATIVE WORKING POSITIONS:>

[one_fourth]

KNEELING

Place a towel under your knee, and alternate every few minutes.[/one_fourth][one_fourth]

<

HIGH/LOW CHAIR

Stand, then sit and hang one leg off at a time, switching sides every few minutes[/one_fourth][one_fourth]

 

STANDING

Try putting one leg on a small stool or box, and alternate every few minutes.[/one_fourth][one_fourth_last]

 

STRETCHING

Stretching while working is a great way to maintain productivity.[/one_fourth_last]

[/framedbox]

Apply this mantra to everything you do throughout your day. Been standing up for a while? Sit down. Sitting down? Stand up! Lay on your stomach while you’re watching TV, sit cross-legged while you read, stand on one foot while you brush your teeth. If you have kids, just watch how they move and how often they move, then imitate them for once.

To borrow again from Katy Bowman: “Exercise is movement, but movement is not always exercise.” Let’s change that! Make the decision to consciously create more movement in your daily life and you can exercise all day long. Instead of thinking of a 30-minute gym workout as your “exercise” for the day, recognize the fact that taking out the trash, choosing stairs over elevators, or jogging down the hall to talk to a colleague are all forms of daily “movement,” and movement is what your body truly needs to function properly.

By transforming your “exercise routine” into a daily “movement practice,” you can drastically decrease those creaks and pains that supposedly show up one morning out of nowhere. Don’t get me wrong, we are human and our bodies will breakdown. Still, I can tell you that by focusing on a daily movement practice, you’ll lower your risk of throwing out your back while doing a mundane task like taking out the trash.

Conclusion

Healing our country’s addiction to a sedentary lifestyle starts with a culture shift within the workplace. We need stop fearing that it’s taboo or unacceptable to leave our desks and move around. We shouldn’t feel weird doing exercises at our desk or standing during a long meeting. And if you are struggling to conjure up ways to get out of your chair and still maintain productivity, ask your PT for help! As movement experts, physical therapists can assess your work/home-life setup and create a personalized movement practice to help alleviate aches and “chronic” pain, and ultimately extend your life.

 


K2Kevin Capata, PT, DPT, CSCS is a licensed physical therapist at Rausch Physical Therapy & Sports Performance. After receiving his Doctor of Physical Therapy degree at Columbia University, Kevin started his career at Rausch PT, where he used to work as a physical therapy aide. Now, Kevin enjoys helping his patients recognize and fix movement faults to help them overcome their injury or pain, as well as empowering them with the knowledge and tools to prevent re-injury or potential new injuries.

Click to learn more about Kevin and our other physical therapists »